Editorial: A Future For Sale
Note: This post is the Administrator's take on how the recent elections went. Fair comments are welcome.
From how I saw it, it was indeed an impressive election. It definitely was more peaceful than the most recent ones. Automation made the process exciting (or worrisome) but at the same time challenging. Truly, it was heartwarming to see people brave the punishing summer heat and the tiring wait just to be able to cast their votes.
There is no doubt in my mind that the results reflected the Abaknons’ true democratic will. However, why they voted for whom is an entirely different issue. I wish to think that in the final analysis, they did vote with the thought of what’s best for Capul.
But even with that, any voter who receives money during election time still compromises his vote. While I do not wish to rob the winners of the glory of their victory, I bet that the aftertaste of their win would have been much sweeter if they (again, i mean ALL of them) did not give money to court the votes of the electorate who themselves showed very little self-respect by being all-too-willing to put a price tag on their votes.
This does not mean though that those who lost are absolved from blame. Some of them may claim that vote-buying was the cause for their downfall but they just have no right complaining about it when they too gave money no matter how miniscule. Their hands are equally dirty.
But even with that, any voter who receives money during election time still compromises his vote. While I do not wish to rob the winners of the glory of their victory, I bet that the aftertaste of their win would have been much sweeter if they (again, i mean ALL of them) did not give money to court the votes of the electorate who themselves showed very little self-respect by being all-too-willing to put a price tag on their votes.
This does not mean though that those who lost are absolved from blame. Some of them may claim that vote-buying was the cause for their downfall but they just have no right complaining about it when they too gave money no matter how miniscule. Their hands are equally dirty.
* * * *
With only about 8,000 registered voters, Capul’s electorate are a small speck in the national scheme of things. No Presidential, Vice-Presidential and Senatorial candidate in his right mind will pour massive funding just to corner this immaterial number.
For the provincial posts, the number could matter in cases of close calls. But yet again, why would candidates concentrate on a remote island where their maneuvers can be limited and easily telegraphed? They would better woo the voters from Catarman, Laverazares or Allen if they want to win significantly. Don't we wonder why for so long, no expansive developmental projects were made in Capul? It's because our number was deemed insignificant vote-wise.
But why is it, that when I checked with other voters from Metro Manila and elsewhere, bigger amounts were given to Abaknons? In those areas, many voters received from Php 300-500, but many others received nothing. But in Capul, more than majority received at least Php 1,500.00! And I say “at least” because I know there were those who received more, either from one or both sides of the political contest.
On the eve of the elections, a leader of one party told me that as we talked, about 4,200 prospective voters have already been given the standard P1,500.00. That already amounts to about P6.3 Million! He said that separate funds have already been given to the candidates to fund their last-minute personal appeals. On the otherhand, the other side also claimed to have finished distributing the envelopes to all those they thought belonged to their fold. And by their survey, a win is likewise apparent.
Pray tell me, where in heaven’s arms did all those oodles of money come from? We have not even inputted yet the logistical costs of the campaign and the money given to people long before election day came!
For chrissakes, will somebody please tell me how these people expect to recover this massive investment from the meager salaries they expected to receive? With a post receiving say Php 30,000 (the average salary of the mayor, vice and councilors), such will only give P 1.2 Million for a 14-month three-year term. Any way you look at it, they lose! Or am I just playing naïve?
I understand that candidates will do everything they can to win. They would even mortgage/sell properties or get usurious loans to bankroll their run. And they would impose upon themselves this supreme sacrifice because of their deep desire to help the people of Capul. Yeah, right.
But it takes two to tango, doesn't it? What happened to the principled electorate? What happened to the idealistic youth vote?
I remember a time when people voted primarily because of kinship or belief in the ability of the candidate. Candidates then would just give out cigarettes or liquor to the roadside “tambays”. With only Php 150.00 per session as honorarium, it was then foolhardy for any councilor-wannabe to spend Php 1,000.00 (for the entire campaign) to solicit votes.
What eroded this ideal scenario where people made choices without money in the equation? It was when the parties received funding support from party-headquarters. Not wanting to be accused of pocketing the money, the leaders divided whatever amount they receive to all their perceived allies. It was not difficult because people then wear their loyalties on their sleeves. Only a few would sit on the fence and become “unreadable”. Wrong recipients would actually return the money shared by the assuming party.
But while the initial intent was honest, that decision triggered the practice of giving out bigger amounts in succeeding elections. Money started becoming a necessary part of the process. From Php 50.00 in one election, to P100.00 to 200 and now P1,500.00! And whereas before only party funds were equally shared, now candidates have to dig deep into their pockets in order to at least hope for victory.
But instead of feeling shame, the voters relished the once-in-a-blue-moon attention and rationalized that getting money is not embarrassing since everyone received anyway. The usual retort was, "it is not vote-buying/selling because they would be voting for their kursunada just the same." How ignorantly wrong! (I suggest they read Sec. 261 of the Omnibus Election Code)
What became a boon for the voters, of course became a bane for the candidates. Not contented with the regular offer, more voters became visibly “unreadable”, as that would assure getting gambits from both sides. The harder-to-get they seemed, the higher the bid. This drama persisted until the very last minute of the election when some would wait in the sidelines for the whispered bids (not just to vote, but also not to vote).
But instead of feeling shame, the voters relished the once-in-a-blue-moon attention and rationalized that getting money is not embarrassing since everyone received anyway. The usual retort was, "it is not vote-buying/selling because they would be voting for their kursunada just the same." How ignorantly wrong! (I suggest they read Sec. 261 of the Omnibus Election Code)
What became a boon for the voters, of course became a bane for the candidates. Not contented with the regular offer, more voters became visibly “unreadable”, as that would assure getting gambits from both sides. The harder-to-get they seemed, the higher the bid. This drama persisted until the very last minute of the election when some would wait in the sidelines for the whispered bids (not just to vote, but also not to vote).
With the passing of the 2010 election, the question now is, at what point is this craziness going to stop? Serving Capul is clearly not an easy task and I am sure it will be very hard to convince prospective public servants to participate in elections where they will be measured in terms of the amount they could give and not the quality of the service they could offer. In the end, Capul will be just the dumpster for those with political capital. But what if the candidates get tired of buying votes? Would there be a time when there will be elections with no candidates? That would be an interesting scenario.
So what's in store for future elections in Capul? With the current trend, we are undoubtedly headed towards more disturbing scenarios. To avert these, allow me to pose this challenge to all future candidates: run without giving out money. Let's allow our people to decide based solely on merit. True, expenses are inevitable but the contending parties could opt to spend only for campaign logistics. If monetary support comes from outside, they could save it for scholarships to the deserving or any other worthy project. What's important is that money no longer gets distributed to individuals.
And of course, the bigger challenge is for the Abaknon electorate. In these times of crisis, it is indeed hard to resist the temptation to receive, more so when everyone else does. But if only we take suffrage as our solemn duty to God and country, we will bear in mind that we could still vote for our favored candidate without asking anything in return. After all, elections are intended to benefit the community and not our individual selves. To that ideal I cross my fingers.
very well said mano and i couldn't agree more.. am helping you in crossing your fingers for that "ideal election scenario" to happen in the next elections...
ReplyDeleteI agree 100%....
ReplyDeletei dont agree with you, dahil khit ikaw naglabas ka ng pera para putangin ang kandidato... for whar purpose??? to buy votes... if what i said is not true dont post it. well u hav ur conscience anyway
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately the trend has started and would be very hard to stop. But.....who knows? Maybe one day....just maybe....
ReplyDeleteLet us just hope and pray for the best!
Anonymous: Ha Ha Ha! I have heard of that rumour too! Sorry to disappoint you but these are the facts: 1. I don't have that much money to be the financier of anybody's campaign. Kuripot po akong tao. 2. If there was anybody who asked for a loan to be used in the campaign, I made it clear that I do not approve of the purpose. So gana nagpautang ko. Pasensiya si ungod magpautang kay si ako dina apumwan i credit. 3. You can ask the campaign leaders if anyone from 24 Sta. Rosa St. received any money. We all paid for our fares going home too. And yes, my conscience is clear.
ReplyDeleteQuestion is, though we really voted for what it is in our heart? Or nadala lang tayo trending? sa kulay? lavander ba? un or yellow or “kursonada”? LOL and LOL again, from my POV there ‘s no such “change” sa political arena upgrade lang ang process really, the blue one is crying out loud in high heavens, I supposed this is with the eagle tattooed? LoL , Main may ako botante ari kita atiya ako si Makati for over 2 decades or so nakita ko ang samot saring pamamaraan para hamok akaabante I adda politiko hahaha si kaawat ko na botante gana pa gayud sa karawat bisan pammal-li adda yosi. LOL, Hopefully soon padi sakulawan na na gayud y nagpinugad “ matured” or educated ba? Nah! im not crossing fingers, crossed legs pwede pa ganyan maihahaluntulad politika sa d2 sa atin parang LBM hindi mapakali. My POV… hehehe
ReplyDeleteit's sometimes understandable if we sell our votes because we need somthing for our meals but that money will not last for long, just remember that in the future they will take that money back from us.In what way? No candidates will spend millions of pesos for their electoral campaign if the don't have any intention to get it back from your wallets.When their maximum salary is just around P30 000, will they earn P 2M pesos in 3 years? I dont think so.If we will continue this kind of mentality "benta ko boto ko" im sure di tayo aasenso.Anyway I did not reciv kahit singko sentimos. Hope next election isipin natin na pag benenta natin ang ating mga boto mas malaking tubo ang kukunin nila para mabalik ang ginastos nila sa election.Alam niyo na po kung saan kayo babalikan ng mga kandidatong yan.
ReplyDeleteIf I am not mistaken, this "vote buying" OR WHAT OTHERS SAY "vote retention" worth more than a thousand pesos started in the 2001 elections, was not that rampant in 2004 but went back to full gear in 2007 & 2010.
ReplyDeleteI still remember a winning politician in 2001 saying these words and I quote "PERA PERA LANG YAN!"
In fairness to the voters, wala naman kasi silang nakikitang pagbabago sa Capul sanglit they take advantage of the situation.
In my experience, some politicians give money to a voter so that they won't switch sides. Meaning, kung walang pera, talagang sila ang iboboto but because of fear na bumaliktad, they just match the money the other side gave.
Anonymous: I agree with you. In most cases, the concept is really more like vote retention - nagbuwanan intero basi gae a tintar pabalyo. But the question is why do we allow this? If we are already loyal to a candidate, why do have to accept the money? Why can't the professionals, the youth and other respectable members of the community reject the offer and treat it as their contribution to the cause of their candidate? I won't be a hypocrite by not accepting the fact that the temptation is greater for our kababayans nga agkuri gayud, pero for the able-bodied others to accept the same is perplexing. How else could the others be led by example if the people they respect are not showing them the way?
ReplyDeleteAnd by the way, the vote-retention concept is no longer as valid as before. For the councilor position I guess it has become first-come-first-served. I have personally known some candidates whose money were rejected because "kadammurihan mayya ag pa lista". Meaning, except probably for their relatives, these people voted not out loyalty to party or candidate but based on who gave the money first.
Capul is a microcosm of mainstream Philippine society when it comes to politics.Every election established clans of elite families wield a great deal of political clout in almost any aspect in local politics.Sometimes, family tiff is unavoidable because candidates vie for some positions with the same family surnames.These powerful clans are very active campaigning, and money flows freely during elections due to the limited number of voters, every vote counts.There are times when candidates for the town council can loose due to a mere 5 votes.
ReplyDeleteIn Capul like that of the national scene, there is a culture of ''turncoatism'' when candidates cross to the other side so as to ensure their winning.Parties coalesce or merge for the convenience to strengthen their base.There is a shifting character of members of leadership as well as lack of ideological or programmatic agenda.Duding elections,families inclined in politics risk their fortune and fame just to win.
ReplyDeleteSpending during elections is openly flaunted since enforcement of the law is not that tight.At the end of the election, the winning party gets choice jobs in the municipal administration.Patronage politics which is practiced by Abaknons, demand that the winning politician having the power of his office must reward the supporters.A politician mustdeliver what he has agreed to produce for political support.
wais na inanto mga botante.
ReplyDeletejust an observation: when i was still tasked to be the emcee during fiestas in san luis, i have to be very careful about the titles i.e. former kagawad, SPO2 (instead of SPO1), former councilor, deck officer 3, administrative officer 2 or what have you. If i forget to mention the title, somebody would berate me on stage for that. So I tell them to ask the fiesta committee to indicate any title whether former or present because I as the emcee is only tasked to read the names of kuratsa dancers.
ReplyDeletenow, we are wondering, why spend a fortune to be elected in a local post? for the title maybe?
so i ask: what's in a name?
ruyag na si mga abaknon inanto taon taon ang election kay maribhong malabbat kwarta na si mga aa.
ReplyDeletemga title eya may nan gayud si kita gana ngani title mo day ay hak pagkakulaw si kaaw...hay buhay..
ReplyDeleteNya ato magpara insister nga niya nagbuwanan ko kwarta para si eleksyon. Sa ka istorya na kuno mismo i nagbuwanan. Kun say kaw, tungguhin istorya moy nan. Dakaw para pa anonymous. Sabihun kun say aaha basi kasayuran kaw. Gana rason ko pagbuwan o pagpautang kwarta si bisan say kay ordinaryo lat hamok ako botante. Tuig hmok ako kapamasahe pagbalik. Makuri si kita kay palain-lain hamok hinimo-himo istorya tapos nagtutuo lat dayun. Grow up!
ReplyDeleteTama kaw kuya and it has been our culture!
ReplyDeleteMakuri nynan abag-o kay tingale si sunod gae na binale bale i piriliay kon nana atta. Katuanan na may kita si Abaknon. People, agree with me! Hehehe!
No comment na kita hamok dawlo kay gae pa may kita kakinda si nagpinugad 'katas ng eleksyon'.
No offense lang!
go mano aryo! mas makuri kay hinimo himo na ngani tapos miskin klarado na i kamatuuran gae pa gyapon ng aksiptar!
ReplyDeletepara si ako hanga ako si mano col.odtujan.kahangahanga ang mga mensahi nya bilang isang candidato d nga lng binigyang pansin ng mga abaknon.dahil kng gusto mo talaga mamuno isunod mo cla sa tama na nkkita mismo sa nmumuno.hayaan mo ang tao iboto ka dahil maytiwala cla sa kakayahan mo or magaling ang isang candidato.ang iba naninira dapat ba un,kaya pamilya nagsira-sira na.MAGMAHALAN TAYO IISANG PAMILYA TAYO SA CAPUL.maiksi lng ang buhay injoy ntin.
ReplyDeleteGna na gad inanto gugma na si botante c adda kandidato kay ag laom na c kwarta permi!Gae na lat nagkulawan e kwalipikasyon ng isang kandidato!Tama ba naman yon?Kallat abaknon pabalik ta e gugma main e tentasyon!
ReplyDeleteComment to Taba: Unfortunately, I have heard that the main purpose of Colonel Odtujan filing his candidacy was to lessen the vote of another Mayoralty candidate and has no intention of winning nor serving us, Abaknons! This is not a good example! NOT AT ALL!!!
ReplyDeleteJust plain Election tactics.
Kaya siguro hindi sya pinansin ng mga Abaknons because he was not serious on his intentions.
Don't tell me na hindi naninira ng kandidato si Colonel Odtujan, 'coz he definitely did!!!
I hope you guys don't find these words offensive as this is OUR (not only my) observation.
its good to talk about this article, para next time it would give us a lesson. a lesson especially to the two of the three mayoral candidates.
ReplyDeletedito kc samen pag nanira ka at ginwan mo ng kwento ang isang kandidato, malamang mwawalan ng respeto sayo ang mga votante.
base on my observation during their campaign isa lang sa kanila ang hndi naninira ng kapwa kandidato ang dalawa halos nagkukutsaba para siraan ang isang kandidato.
well... thats why he won cguro kasi marunong siyang rumespeto khit sinisiraan na xa especially ang alam ko tito nya ang isa at ang isa naman ay family frend nila.
and basi rin sa mga kwento kaya hndi sia naninira ng kapwa kandidato bec mai pinirmahan pla silang covenant of peace, na hindi sinunud ng dalawa. well so much for dat..
yan ang dapat mag lead sa mga ABAKNONS mai respeto sa kapwa capuleno at hndi marunong manira ng kapwa abaknon.
i havent heard of this elected mayor until he bacame a councilor.at marami daw xang nagawa. kung sa pakalian bi i speech nia ng meeting de avance ari bungto.. makakabalyo gad gayod.. he seems to be a nice person. lets just wait and see if he kud really win the hearts of the abaknons and lead capul to a new capul.